Operating a modern water or desalination plant is demanding. Operators and maintenance teams must keep the plant producing the required amount of water, maintain equipment.
From Wastewater to 98.7% water Recovery: What a Mountain Lake Pilot Shows About the Limits of Reverse Osmosis

Every water reuse project faces a limit often set by the brine composition rather than the membranes themselves. As reverse osmosis recovery is pushed higher, salts and other contaminants become increasingly concentrated, allowing scaling and fouling to take hold.
At Big Bear Lake, California, a demonstration project was pushed toward this limit and successfully met its target to turn 90% of challenging wastewater effluent into reusable water. It went a step further reaching 98.7%, while keeping the system running stably, producing water suitable for snowmaking and irrigation.
Here’s what made it possible, and why this could matter for communities that have limited options to dispose of their brine.
A resort community with a water problem
Big Bear Valley is a popular year-round resort in California’s San Bernardino Mountains. Like much of California, it has faced drought and decline of lake levels. In response, the local water agency developed the Replenish Program aims to help restore the Big Bear lake levels and create a reliable new water source, a supply of recycled water for snowmaking, landscape irrigation and groundwater recharge.
For the local wastewater treatment plant that meant producing water clean enough for unrestricted reuse and discharge into a lake that is essential to the community’s economy and identity. That set a high bar. Treatment had to meet strict discharge and reuse water quality standard while producing as little brine as possible. After all, recovering more water is only one part of the equation, every cubic meter of remaining concentrated brine needs somewhere to go.
With that in mind, the project team set four goals for the membrane treatment stage:
- Achieve at least 90% water recovery from treated wastewater
- Minimize brine volume to reduce disposal needs and environmental impact
- Demonstrate stable long-term operation with minimal operator intervention
- Reduce reliance on evaporation ponds, which use land space and are costly to operate
Why this effluent is hard to treat
The water was fed with wastewater effluent, a challenging starting point for high recovery RO process. Key feed water quality parameters included the following:
- TOC: 8.0 mg/L, above the typical RO design guidelines
- Silica: 25.7 mg/L
- Calcium: 62 mg/L
- Sulfate: 140 mg/L
- TDS: 617 mg/L
This combination creates three major obstacles on the system way toward achieving high recovery.
- Fouling in the final membranal elements. In conventional RO systems, crossflow velocity decreases toward the tail end of the membrane train. With less shear force to sweep the membrane surface, particles and organic matter can settle on the last membranes in the line.
- Biofouling. Steady operating conditions can drive toward biofilms growth and attachment. The high organic loading adds to the problem, supporting biological growth on the membranes.
- Scaling. As permeate water is recovered, sparingly soluble salts such as calcium carbonate, calcium phosphate and silica can exceed their solubility limits and precipitate on the membrane surface.
All three problems become harder to manage as recovery increases. At 95% recovery the concentration factor reaches 20. That means any extra 5 ppm of silica in the feed is translated into an additional 100 ppm in the brine. In conventional RO system this issue is addressed by increasing the antiscalant doses, applying cleaning procedures more frequently or setting for lower recovery. Furthermore, none of these means solve the underlying problem when the brine has nowhere to go.
Two technologies, two jobs
IDE’s approach doesn’t depend on one technology doing everything. The key is combining two technologies, PFRO (Pulse-Flow-Reverse-Osmosis) and Desalter. The brine leaving PFRO still contains water that can be recovered by MAXH2O Desalter, that integrated fluidized bed reactor (FBR) with RO process and thus overcoming the scaling limits of the PFRO brine.
At the first stage the PFRO runs in cycles instead of steady state. It alternates between production mode and flushing mode. Flushing creates high shear across the membrane surface, which removes deposits before it established into scale or develop into biofilm. The ongoing changing conditions help to prevent biofouling. The regular hydraulic flush replaces major part of the chemical cleaning requirements in the conventional system.
The PFRO brine still holds valuable water, and the MAXH2O Desalter recovers it in the second stage. The Desalter combines high recovery RO with an integrated fluidized bed reactor (FBR) in a semi batch process. As the brine becomes more concentrated, sparingly soluble salts such as calcium sulfate, calcium carbonate and silica are precipitated in the FBR reactor instead of buildup on the membrane. The effluent stream of the FBR that returns to the RO has a low scaling potential and enables the membranes to run at high recovery without losing service life. The Desalter is also designed to manage changes in feed water quality, an important feature when the feed is the brine from previous treatment stage.
The two stages are complementary. PFRO recovers most of the water while managing fouling under control. The Desalter then recovers additional water from the remaining concentrated brine, where scaling becomes the bigger challenge. Together, they address both sides of the problem: keeping membranes clean and managing the salts that limit recovery.

What the field demonstration showed
The integrated system was tested at Big Bear Valley, with the performance of each stage evaluated both individually and as part of the combined process.
PFRO performance: The PFRO demonstration unit runs continuously for more than 15 weeks presenting 86% recovery. It also runs for a period of six-days at 90%. During the run the specific flux was dropped by only 10%, without applying any Clean-in-Place (CIP). Normalized head loss was kept stable, meaning fouling was under control. Permeate quality consistently meets treatment targets.
Desalter performance: Treating the PFRO brine, the MaxH2O Desalter recovered an additional 86–91% of the water while keeping permeate conductivity stable. Differential pressure was kept stable, meaning that scaling was under control. Silica is the most notable result. At the test concentrations using the PFRO brine as feed to the Desalter, silica could theoretically have exceeded 1,000 mg/L. Yet, the silica in the Desalter brine was kept below 200 mg/L. The Desalter also removed more than 50% of total organic carbon through coprecipitation helping to manage the high organic load in the raw water.
Together, the two stages achieved 98.7% overall water recovery. PFRO recovered 86% of the feedwater, and the MaxH2O Desalter recovered approximately 91% of the remaining brine. The recovered water met the quality requirements for unrestricted reuse, including snowmaking and landscape irrigation, two key applications targeted by the Replenish Program.
Wish to learn more about this project? Watch the full webinar here >> https://ide-tech.com/en/resource/98-7-recovery-in-wastewater-treatment-best-global-demo-results/
Why 98.7% changes
Increasing from 90% to 98.7% may seem modest, but in terms of brine volume, it makes a substantial difference. At 90% recovery, 10% of the feedwater remains as concentrate. At 98.7%, that drops to just 1.3%. It is roughly one-eighth of the brine volume to dispose.
For a community that relies on evaporation ponds, a small brine stream can substantially reduce the pond capacity needed. That means less land, lower construction costs and fewer long-term management obligations.
How the system reached that recovery matters just as much as the number itself. High recovery over a short trial is one thing; sustaining it without heavy chemical dosing or frequent cleaning is another. This demonstration provided encouraging evidence of operational stability: 15 weeks of continuous PFRO operation, three months without cleaning-in-place (CIP), and stable differential pressure in the MaxH2O Desalter. For utilities, that matter reuse systems need to perform reliably year after year, not just during a trial.
The results should also be viewed in context. This was a demonstration, not a full-scale plant, and questions about scale-up and long-term performance remain. Even so, the project showed that this combination of technologies could achieve ultra-high recovery from challenging wastewater effluent, maintain stable operation over the test period, and produce water that met the requirements for unrestricted reuse.
Conclusion: Making brine management central to the design
The Big Bear project shows the difference when brine management becomes the starting point of design rather than a problem left to the end. By combining a pulse flow RO stage that manages fouling with a Desalter that removes scale-forming compounds through controlled precipitation, the system achieved a level of recovery that would be difficult to sustain with conventional RO alone on this challenging feed.
The approach could offer a path forward for inland utilities, mountain resorts and industrial sites facing strict discharge limits or limited brine disposal options. For these communities and businesses, managing the remaining brine can make the difference between a viable reuse project and one that never gets built.
Could ultra-high recovery help address your water reuse or brine management challenge? Contact IDE’s team to explore the possibilities.






